DEI Made the Forest Service a Better Place to Work and it Still Is

The US Forest Service became a better agency and place to work when it put some focus, priority, and structure on diversity, equity, and inclusion (aka “DEI”). And I'm betting that it still is.

I was a USFS employee for just short of thirty-four years starting in 1990. I started my career as the first full time wildlife biologist on the Walker Ranger District of the Chippewa National Forest in north central Minnesota. The majority of the Chippewa NF land base is within the boundaries of the Leech Lake Indian Reservation.

Most of the employees on my ranger district and the national forest were like me - white males. There were more women being hired (almost all Caucasian), but none were in top leadership positions and few were in positions of significant influence. As I can recall, there were some Native American employees including two on our District. I remember just one African-American employee and there might have been one or two of Hispanic, Asian, or mixed race ethnicity.

Despite being a white male, I was in some ways unusual coming with a couple of advanced degrees and a former job at a small college. While I was welcomed, there was a little distance from some employees. This discomfort was relatively minor and nothing like what I knew others were feeling, just by their ethnicity and skin color.

I was curious about how the Native American employees felt having grown up on the reservation, which was not an exclusive place where only Indian people lived, but in communities that varied from predominantly white to predominantly Native American. Most of them held fairly low graded positions in administration or technician series jobs. They no doubt knew that the land then owned by the United States Government and administered as a national forest had once been part of the territory of the Ojibway nation until it was ceded to the United States in a treaty. I’m not sure what the non-native employees knew about that; it was not a topic discussed much at that time. Back then, there was almost no direction, little interest, and even less effort to engage the native communities and the Native American employees in decisions about land management, their traditional knowledge about how Nature worked, or the culture of the Forest Service. I am guessing that those employees didn’t feel much inclusion and that any diversity they represented was just a statistic. Equity for them did not exist.

I eventually moved on from the Chippewa National Forest and eventually moved up in the organization. I spent time in a Regional Office and served as a Regional Deputy Director, Deputy Forest Supervisor, Forest Supervisor, and Regional Director. In these roles I had a chance to lead by example and to support and acknowledge employees for positive efforts and outcomes. I believed that people who felt welcome, understood, and valued would be the best people they could be while they were working. I believed that people should work in a safe working environment, physically, emotionally, and intellectually. This required among other things, efforts around inclusion, such as, ensuring that there was equitable time to be heard, ideas respected even if not agreed with, and tolerance and appreciation for different ways of both seeing the world and behaving in it.

As part of a senior leader development program at the beginning of my last twenty years of working, I developed and adopted a leadership approach that included emphasis on the concepts of empathy, trust, and tolerance, which collectively supported the agency’s burgeoning desires around diversity, equity, and inclusion.

For me, empathy required each of us to assume that everyone who comes to work is carrying burdens, many of them likely similar to our own. Through true empathy we could adopt a posture that helped others know that they were not alone and that they were understood. I had my own burdens tried to not allow them to affect the quality and quantity of my work, but sometimes they did. I openly told employees and colleagues about some of them and that I shared burdens similar to what they experienced. The travails of life were an equal opportunity provider and we all had lifetime subscriptions.

Trust was starting with the assumption that everyone was trying their best when they were working. Some days the burdens we carried made our best look more like our worst. I purposely told people when I could see that I had not had my best days and asked for their understanding. This helped me and many employees feel more comfortable about vulnerability and led to an understanding that we were essentially all ships floating on the same turbulent seas of life and could share when we felt like we were floundering and taking on metaphorical water.

Tolerance was about expecting everyone to be different, in how they spoke and acted. It took me a good many years to become tolerant of other ways of thinking, speaking, and doing and to move from simple tolerance to embracing everyone's individuality. I recall a moment early in my career when what I had to say and how I was saying it was not resonating well. My supervisor came to me later to say how much she appreciated the ideas I offered. How I felt at that moment helped me identify how I wanted all others to feel - accepted, understood, and appreciated.

Over the two decades I was in leadership roles, I witnessed growth in myself and many others. One of the most influential and inspiring actions I discovered in the last few years of my career was the establishment of a multicultural group by a small group of employees who wanted to use their lunch break time to explore topics around diversity, equity, and inclusion by inviting people to simply tell stories. Technology allowed for virtual participation across the country. I joined the group well after it started and listened keenly to employees whom I would otherwise never have the chance to encounter in my role. They talked from their hearts about the culture of their ethnicity, their gender, their history, and their own experiences before and after joining the Forest Service. Their stories were engaging and powerful. I was humbled by how little I knew, by how committed and optimistic the participants were, and by what their ongoing careers could do to help the agency be more resilient and adapted to an inevitable future of change and connection to society as a whole.

That group was just one of many that self-started, that did not need agency funds or direction, and was committed to being in it for the long run. Perhaps that group no longer has the support of a little time spent in their discussions from current senior leaders of the agency. Perhaps they no longer can advertise the availability of their gatherings to any employees interested in attending. They may be suffering a bit from that, but I have no doubt that their resolve has not been lessened and that they are finding other ways to connect and share.

Collectively, the efforts and results from both programmed and self-started activities in support of diversity, equity, and inclusion were difficult to measure and evaluate, but I left the agency after more than three decades and retired a couple of years ago with the following conclusions:

We learned from each other. By being curious and hearing first hand about people’s backgrounds and their experiences we gained understanding and had a chance to have and demonstrate empathy about their life circumstances and how they affected that person.

We embraced differing points of view and were openly grateful whenever we heard ideas that were influential no matter who they came from.

We discovered how what we considered to be normal and perhaps “equal treatment” did not get everyone’s boat to float at the same level and discussed and took actions that helped pull other employees to a place in which they felt they were being heard and respected in line with others.

We learned that equity is not equality. Discussions about equity helped us understand that treating everyone the same (equality) did not produce the desired result because there were longstanding and current attitudes and practices that created barriers and different starting places for everyone. Those discussions opened our minds, and I daresay the hearts, of many, that our desires for people to have equitable treatment would require inclusive attitudes and behaviors, and that the diversity of employees expressed in many ways, which would make us stronger, more creative, and more resilient to change, would thrive in such an environment, even if it created more challenges than the "good old boy" culture in which you knew pretty much what to expect from everyone because they were more alike than different.

We came to realize that inclusion is the container in which diversity can be nested and can thrive because the environment and culture genuinely included people of all backgrounds and was promoting equitable treatment.

We began looking at the differences of others not as something that would cause more challenges, but as the potential for new and rewarding ideas, knowledge, and possibilities.

And as in all other agencies and institutions in which white males dominated the workforce and culture for a long time, we also came to understand that there could easily be some feelings of lost value and disenfranchisement of white male employees that needed legitimate recognition, attention, and empathy.

We did not solve all of the shortcomings of the agency in these areas, but we moved the ball down the playing field a ways and overcame a good deal of inertia. In fact, we created momentum by the “weight” of employees and the intensity of their desires and actions.

The Trump Administration has directed agencies to “get rid of DEI” in federal agencies without a convincing explanation of what gains will be made and why those gains are important. I have news for the President and his followers who think DEI is something that can just be eliminated by edict, lack of funding, and changed priorities. You are too late. Yes, the programs, funding, and specific direction that you eliminated had helped, but making the Forest Service a better place to work through learning, understanding, adjusting attitudes, and committing to actions that make all employees feel welcome, valued, and included has now permeated the agency and touched people’s minds and I daresay, hearts. They get it, support it, and will continue to make efforts to further it along.

By the way, these efforts didn’t and won’t make the agency “woke”, wildly radical, unable to carry out its mission for the benefits of the American people, etc. Instead, they make the agency the kind of place where a wider diversity of people want to work and should be working to best serve the needs of the breadth of America’s multicultural society. I remain proud to have spent almost all of my professional career with the U.S. Forest Service and to have contributed a little to making it a better place to work so that its goals of “being an employer of choice” and of “serving the American public by taking care of the land” can be realized.

Comments